A good referee report helps in publishing highquality results thereby eliminating fake studies as it focusses on the soundness of the study and provides effective feedback. Be sure that your decision is not stated in the report itself, only the letter. Includes a report writing checklist for use by students. Because of space constraints, at least 80% of submitted manuscripts cannot not be published. A good referee report has the following components. New jobs are the lifeblood of any thriving region and can ensure economic health and prosperity for years to come. The aim of your report is to help the journal to decide if the work is suitable to publish.
For more guidance for your future reference, the institute of physics has a great online resource on introduction to refereeing, that deals. Scan the corrected manuscript to pdf file, and upload it with this referee report form. The purpose of a referee report is to recommend to an editor whether a paper is. How to write a referee report in this section we will outline the important steps involved in preparing and writing a referee report. Writing fraud examination reports 16 report writing example this report reflects that collins, a purchasing agent for bailey books, inc.
The essential stages of successful report writing are described below. The same information should be provided as for printed books, see examples above. Fall 2004 are 251 econ 270a guidelines for referee reports. Referee report the first section of the report often one paragraph should contain a concise summary of the papers claimed results, contributions, and general line of reasoning. Hence, whether the paper is good or not, and you think it deserves publication or not, your job is to document for the editor reasons for accepting. Chapter 10 writing the research paper 161 interest your reader the immediate context in which you are writing the paper provides one set of clues. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The editor is typically not an expert in the papers subfield, so it is important for this summary to be clear. There is no need to use all caps, exclamation points, or complicated analogies. At the same time, it is important that the referee and editorial evaluation provide the author with useful feedback on his manuscript even if it is. For books that have been read or downloaded from a library website or bookshop you should add information about e book at the end of the reference.
In writing your report to be seen by the author, lead off with a succinct summary of the paper, or move immediately to. As you pursue a career as a professional economist, writing referee reports will become part of. You dont have to be a great writer to produce good economics writing. Referee report, cover letter, ethics, conflicts of interest. Referee guidelines v33 american economic association. The editors thank you in advance for the invaluable service that you will provide to the authors. Many editors request a referee s report that will be sent to the author and a cover letter with your recommendation about publication. A concise statement of the contribution of the paper to the literature.
This manual will advise authors on how to prepare papers to improve their chances for. As you may well be writing your report as an assignment, you must reference all the sources you use in the body of the report and always have a reference list whenever you are asked to write a report at university. Phd course in corporate finance how to write a referee report. Turn in your cover letter, report, and the paper by. And that these kinds of report forms are critical, most especially when it comes to the applicant appraisal or assessment. Economic development reference guide acknowledgements verizon verizons mission is to open doors for economic development and to build relationships and partnerships that help create and retain jobs in verizon communities. Popular economics books showing 150 of 41,190 freakonomics. Those referees in sports andor events are the ones who make sure that all the rules of the game are adhered, obeyed, or followed by the players or participants, whereas the referees in businesses or any application are those who are appointed to examine or assess ones work, skills, behavior, and characteristics. With the new scheme introduced by the icai, students registered with the old syllabus i. Guidelines for your referees report in the course of this class, you will be asked to write two 2 referee reports on assigned papers that are at the working paper stage. Pdf writing an article for a refereed accounting journal. Once a referee report is received, it is important not to take the comments too. Bwf hhmi 3 writing a letter of recommendation for people who are not in your labask for a current cv that includes the dates and locations of their training and a list of publications as well as copies of any papers that are in press or that have been submitted. Dont publish a book, at least not before getting tenure.
Business and report writing skills carissa michel 1. Turn in your cover letter, report, and the paper by 5pm friday of last full week of classes. A rogue economist explores the hidden side of everything hardcover by. I suggest that you read her essay not only when writing sucha report but also when drafting your. If you think the paper is good, in practice you suggest a revise and resubmit and try to offer both constructive comments to the author, and specific guidance for the editor on what needs to be done to make the paper publishable. I read referee reports that list a bunch of questions and suggested changes. This section seems perhaps bestsuited for papers grounded in economics or other disciplines. Most referee reports must ultimately lead to a decision by a jme editor not to publish the manuscript. Tips for writing referee reports university of illinois. William thomson a guide for the young economist cambridge. Write a cover letter stating your decision to accept, reject, or most likely confer a revise and resubmit judgment on the paper and the key issues behind your decision.
To develop or continue their understanding of business writing, report writing and business reporting language. Levitt shelved 4280 times as economics avg rating 3. The writing of a report by a student in the statistics department of the athens university of economics and business from the book the teaching of practical statistics by c. This lets the author and editor know you understood what the author was trying to say. Here are a few suggestions for referee report writing. Referee reports are mandatory due to the fact that these reports are part of the recruitment and selection process. This is for the reason that these contain decisive and crucial importance in the individuals success andor failure. This is not always required in a report in the workplace, although crediting the sources you have used is a courtesy. It also helps the authors improve the manuscript before it is published. Write a comment about the manuscript in the box provided below. My view based on writing, being a referee, an dissertation supervisor, and editor is that empirical papers that have a lot of typos also. Hansen 2000, 20201 university of wisconsin department of economics this revision. The journal of monetary economics has a long tradition of providing authors with an excellent set of referees that go beyond advising the editors on their final decision, but crucially improve the quality of the research that gets published at the jme and elsewhere.
Writing a letter of recommendation mrc cognition and. B u s i n e s s a n d r e p o r t w r i t i n g s k i l l s a t c s u v e r s i o n 1. Pdf a handbook on writing research paper in social sciences. The two purposes of the report is to summarize a given paper, and offer comments or suggestions to help an author improve the paper. All reports need to be clear, concise and well structured. The composition basics section focuses on grammar including punctuation. With careful planning, the writing of a report will be made much easier. Key the parenthetical reference one space after the ending punctuation mark. If you are writing the research paper as part of an academic course, the issues raised in class and the particulars of the.
Citation style for papers and theses in economics t. Provides an outline of an example report and a summary of the main elements a report should include. Using 20 words when you can use one will impress no one. Please answer the following referee report form regarding the manuscript english level. Download icai ca foundation study material aug 2020 in. Guidelines for your referees report faculty of arts. Speak plainly, but dispassionately in the same tone as you would in writing a manuscript. The book is carefully set out to guide students step by step through the maze of assignment types, writing conventions and mysterious vocabulary they will. Glencoe keyboarding with computer applicationsacademic report format guide 7. May 2020 comments welcome 1this manuscript may be printed and reproduced for individual or instructional use, but may not be printed for commercial purposes. A guide to writing in econo mics prepared by paul dudenhefer, writing tutor, ecoteach center and department of economics, duke university introduction 5 part i.
A comparison summary this paper compares various riskadjusted performance measures for a set of mutual funds. Overall, dont be afraid to have strong opinions and perhaps be. Six principles of clear, cohesive, and coherent writing 12. The journal of economic perspectives is currently published by american economic association. If the paper is not worth publishing, your referee report should provide criticisms of the paper. The key to writing an effective report is to allocate time for planning and preparation. Harvey, and david hirshleifer drawing on insights of current and past editors of top economics and finance journals, we. Phd course in corporate finance how to write a referee report ernst maug 1 revised may 17, 2012 1 ernst maug, professor of corporate finance, university of mannheim. First, the discourse is often mathematical, with lots of formulas, lemmas, and proofs. Make an unpublishable paper publishable by directing the research. An example of a twoline abstract of this report follows. The young economists guide to professional etiquette. Preparing a referee report american economic association. Are 251 econ 270a guidelines for referee reports the purpose of a referee report is to recommend to an editor whether a paper is suitable for publication or not, potentially after revision.
529 1263 1169 1315 512 1481 750 121 127 1564 575 785 377 1138 1100 1359 845 176 1083 285 1470 253 377 1573 104 542 1252 294 273 564 623 189 1086 865 51 1321